iambriansreed
2014-11-13 00:52:07 UTC
我們有3個孩子，目前正在設法使它們適合Accord（媽媽）和Civic（爸爸）。公民很緊張，但在大多數情況下，公民是一個父母，有一個孩子。
我們最近發現4號車即將到來，關於小型貨車或SUV的激烈爭論再次出現。我們還有幾個月的戰鬥時間，但我（爸爸）想要麵包車，媽媽想要飛行員。
每種汽車都有哪些明顯的優點和缺點？
是否有任何理由說服我的妻子說麵包車是更好的選擇，還是我不滿意？
>除了麵包車或SUV之外，第三排座位還有其他選擇嗎？
年齡為12、7、1.5，-6個月。而且沒有科學的可能性了。 ：/
大部分時間哪個父母會開車？主駕駛員在決策過程中獲得優勢... :)
There are lots of things to consider, but think about cargo space. I grew up in a house with 4 kids and we had a big van. We would take road trips a lot and being able to comfortably fit the whole family plus luggage plus whatever else made things much easier.
我必須投票結束基於觀點的意見；在我看來，它沒有正確地寫成“主觀上好的”問題。關於哪個更可取，不可能存在“共識”，因為人們確實會兩者都買。為了成為一個可以接受的問題，您可以要求更具體的功能等，但是僅問“我應該買哪個”是基於觀點的，而不是主題。
媽媽在說什麼在中排的飛行員中，您必須退出車輛，以允許任何人進出後排；有時是交通方面。一個好的迷你吧將帶中央小島和雙推拉門。
@Joe如果詢問*我如何說服我的重要同伴該家庭需要一輛小型貨車，它將獲得相同的答案。不是玩具*。
AiligtattvCMT it could be rephrased to ask about the advantages/disadvantages of each, less a matter of opinion and more a description of typical vehicle features.
沒有其他限制的“我應該買什麼，X或Y”是個壞問題，因為它們是基於意見的，個性化的-僅關注提問者，對其他人沒有用-往往沒有足夠的細節來回答問題。這個問題有所有這些問題。實際上，您可以從一些答案中看出。詢問者處於下雪狀態還是溫暖狀態？他住在城市，郊區，郊區還是鄉村？是否有家庭成員殘障或極度矮小？
There are a _lot_ of different reasons you might buy an SUV versus a Minivan, and it's very hard to answer that, particularly as asked. It *is* possible to ask, When choosing a vehicle for a large family, what are the advantages and disadvantages of a minivan versus an SUV; and it is possible to include additional information in the question to make the answers more useful. None of that is present here, so it is _not_ on topic.
The answers as given actually largely answer a somewhat better question - but the question needs to be edited into that somewhat better question form, not just answering the better question without doing the editing. It's not enough for the answers to be good; the _question_ should be good, as well, and _particularly_ so for a question very likely to hit the Hot Questions feed like this one - we want this to be a good representation of our site to others.
Jeez @Joe對不起，您的玉米片。
AilihsfbdvCMT if you feel an edit would improve the question, please feel free to do so.
I think the (now edited) version of this question is a great example of where our engine can shine for questions that can feel subjective. The key test for me is whether it can generate answers that most with experience would agree hit the key information that the OP and others in similar quandaries would need, and this one does.
I suggest horse and buggy.
AiliekznyqCMT I can't down vote comments but I can flag. ;)
小型貨車很棒。我不僅可以攜帶整個家庭，還可以搬家具和其他物品。如果您有兩個以上的孩子，那麼乘坐麵包車肯定不會錯:)我喜歡我的本田奧德賽。