Janet G
2014-12-08 05:55:22 UTC
有人告訴我，我10個月大的孫子在站著沙發或桌子的時候不斷彈跳，使臀部受傷。他看起來非常健康和堅強。有健康風險嗎？
我認為，正是按照要求，這個問題必須解決，因為它是一個醫療問題：“是否存在健康風險？”。我們不應該通過這裡的問題來判斷是否存在任何健康風險（因為我們不認識孩子，也不能確切地說絕對沒有風險，因為許多常見的活動都包括一些小風險）。我認為將該詞組調整為“這是否正常嗎？”沒有任何問題，如果達成普遍共識，將對其進行編輯。
Is a question of the form "Is X a health risk?" really a medical question? I can see it being borderline, but if it has a general answer that can be documented and that's appropriate for children without special medical conditions, I don't see how it's any more inappropriate than other typical questions. There's hardly any question about babies that doctors won't have an educated opinion on, but I don't think that reaches the scope of a "medical question" unless it's specifically about treatment of an illness or similar.
"Is X a health risk" is effectively asking "is it safe to do X". To the extent medical questions are not acceptable here, I think this wouldn't be also, worded that specific way: any liability concern would exist ("Is skateboarding down Main Street a health risk?" for example) and on the other hand, imagine "Is throwing my baby in the air a health risk?": the fact that sometimes the answer is "maybe" and depends on specific information makes it (to me) a medical question. Like I said - take away those words and make it "is it normal" or something like that and it's avoiding that grey area.
我認為這裡不存在健康風險，但重點是，如果相同結構的某些問題實際上是醫學問題，則也必須以這種方式表述。至少在我的腦海裡（這就是為什麼我問而不是僅僅編輯的原因）。
AE's answer, on the other hand, shows how this can have a very good answer (at least mostly) as written; maybe I'm just picking nits on the specific wording. I do think that the top answers are, while accurate, not what I'd want to see as answering the question as written, and is why I voiced this concern: while Anongoodnurse is a medical professional and a good source in and of herself, it's very easy to see answers from non-professionals that are basically "no" without sources, and that makes me worry about venturing into medical advice.
彈跳超過30年；除了總是被要求停止搖動桌子以外，沒有其他問題。
我兒子到處跑了9.5個月。六個月前，他的雙腳彈跳起來。現在快樂，健康11yo！
@Joe這個站點上的每個問題最終都至少與一般（即使不是非常狹窄和具體）意義上的健康相關。
AiliyzgqqyCMT exactly. "Is activity X a health risk?" can be interpreted as a 'health question' for any X. Going to the play farm, eating dirt, playing with sand, leaving the house ... I don't see any logic behind us trying to avoid the word 'health'. Obviously it would be inappropriate for anyone here to try to make medical diagnoses over the internet, but anything/everything has a 'health' aspect.